Found this listing quite randomly but immediately fell in love with the pictures. Worked it out to stay over Labor Day weekend, us and another couple, and was really glad it worked out.
Home is away from the popular, trendy center of town - which is just what we were looking for. Indeed, it checked a lot of boxes for us: quiet, private, excellent well-kept pool, overall comfortable living space, lots of greenery, roomy kitchen, fully stocked towels and linens, and on and on.
Was a little pricier than we were hoping for originally, but in the end, it was definitely worth the extra expense. And we're already thinking about when we might be able to stay again next year.