Spacious 2BR Cottage in Pinecraft • Near Beaches & Downtown Sarasota

Spacious 2BR Cottage in Pinecraft • Near Beaches, Dining & Downtown

Casa Grapefruit is a bright and welcoming 2-bedroom, 1-bathroom cottage located in the peaceful, walkable Pinecraft community — Sarasota’s historic Amish/Mennonite village. Ideal for families, couples traveling together, or small friend groups, this cottage is centrally located just minutes from the beach, downtown Sarasota, and cultural attractions.

Now under new ownership, the property is being refreshed with improved amenities, guest supplies, and outdoor spaces.

This 2BR cottage includes:

One queen bedroom with closet

Second bedroom with twin bunk beds

Living room with cozy seating

Full kitchen: microwave, fridge, stove/oven, cookware, dishes, and more

Private entry, shared outdoor space, and access to shared on-site laundry

Dedicated driveway parking plus additional street parking

Perfect for:

Families with kids needing separate sleep space

Two couples splitting the cost

Multi-week seasonal guests looking for value + location

Guests can walk to local favorites like Yoder’s Restaurant, Big Olaf Ice Cream, and Amish produce markets — all within a few blocks. Pinecraft Park and bike rentals are also nearby.

In just 10–15 minutes, you can reach:

Siesta Key Beach

St. Armands Circle & Lido Key

Marie Selby Botanical Gardens

Downtown Sarasota’s dining and arts district

Casa Grapefruit is part of a 4-unit property (Casa Orange, Casa Lime, Casa Lemon), each offering privacy with shared amenities. Perfect for families or friends booking together.

Whether you're here for sunshine, Sarasota culture, or slow-paced relaxation, this cottage delivers a comfortable and welcoming stay.