Charming Bayfront Cottage in Heart of Islamorada with Pool, Dockage, Beach, Kayaks & More

The Bay View Cottage is a charming two-bedroom, one-bath home tucked beneath the shade of mature trees along the bayfront at Mermaid's Bay Boutique Estate—a private 3.5-acre waterfront retreat in the heart of downtown Islamorada. With peaceful views of the Florida Bay and a shaded front porch that stays cool throughout the day, this cozy cottage is ideal for couples or small families seeking a laid-back island escape.

Inside, the home is filled with warmth and character, blending vintage touches with simple comforts. The layout includes two bedrooms—one with a king bed and the other with two queen beds—plus a shared bathroom. The open living area connects to a thoughtfully stocked kitchen and dining space, with French doors that let in soft natural light and frame views of the bay.

Just outside, the large front porch features a cushioned outdoor sofa and casual seating, perfect for relaxing any time of day while soaking in the sights and sounds of the water just steps away.

As part of Mermaid's Bay Boutique Estate, guests of the Bay View Cottage enjoy access to shared, resort-style amenities including a heated pool and spa, a private sandy beach with hammocks and lounge chairs, a large protected boat basin with a small boat ramp, and complimentary kayaks, paddle boards, and bikes. Each home on the estate has its own private porch, grill, and designated parking.

Additional in-home amenities include a washer and dryer, filtered water dispenser, and thoughtfully provided starter supplies such as paper goods, toiletries, and coffee essentials—everything you need to settle in comfortably and enjoy your stay.

Tucked away just off the main road yet within walking distance of Islamorada's best restaurants, shops, breweries, and marinas, the Bay View Cottage offers the perfect balance of privacy, charm, and access to everything the Keys have to offer.

This home is offered as a relaxing getaway for families and friends. The primary renter must be at least 25 years of age and present for the duration of the stay. Parties, events, and similar celebrations are not permitted. Pets (if allowed) must be pre-approved, visitors outside the registered guest list are not allowed, and occupancy may not exceed the stated limit. The home and its amenities are for the enjoyment of registered guests only. By booking, guests agree to these guidelines, which are in place to help ensure a safe and enjoyable stay for everyone.

Pricing and availability shown in instant quotes and calendars are estimates and may change without prior notice. For the most accurate information, please contact us directly.

This property is locally managed by Solace Properties. Once your booking is confirmed, you'll receive a rental agreement via email to review and sign. Rental payments are processed directly through Solace Properties, while VRBO collects their service fee separately. We kindly prefer payment by personal check or eCheck, but credit cards are also accepted with a 3% convenience fee. For any questions or assistance, Solace Properties will be your main point of contact.