We enjoyed our week at Susan's house on Orient Point. The house is located right on the LI Sound, with its own little strip of beach out front. It is a quiet and relaxing spot. The kitchen is well-equipped, and we cooked in for most of our meals. Also, Susan was responsive to a few of issues that came up.
That said, the house seems to perhaps be in need of some TLC. Some screen doors were damaged/missing, and some moldings were loose/fallen off. Although it is a personal aesthetic, we found the furniture to be a bit outdated. And as the pictures accurately show, the house is quite tchotchke-laden.
The beach in front is very rocky and strewn with boulders and washed-up trees. Definitely worth bringing rubber shoes for walking and swimming. Also, being out at Orient Point, Greenport and Southold are a bit of a ride. So, you need to plan your grocery shopping/dining excursions accordingly.
Overall, a lovely stay. But some may feel the house is a tad "rustic", especially considering the price.