5BR/5.5BA Ensuites, Private Cottage, Dog Friendly,Seasonal Pool May-Sep

200-year-old private estate on 1.3 acres, just minutes from Cape May's beaches. Two buildings, 5 bedrooms each with its own ensuite bath, and a private 700 sq ft pool with pickleball court and cornhole in the backyard. Smart lock check-in, parking for 6, and space for up to 14 guests. Superhost with a Top Guest Favorite badge and 5.0 stars across every review.


A note from a recent guest

"This property has everything you could dream of and more! Plus a bathroom in every bedroom! We loved hanging out by the pool and playing pickleball during our stay." - Brynn, June 2026 (5.0★)

THE ESTATE

Cape May Reserve is a 200-year-old historic estate on 1.3 private acres, just a few minutes from the beach. The property has two separate buildings, the Main House and a detached Cottage, that together sleep up to 14 guests across 5 bedrooms, each with its own private ensuite bathroom. No sharing, no waiting. Two full kitchens, one per building.

Self check-in via smart lock, so you arrive on your own schedule. Parking for up to 6 cars in the main driveway.

THE MAIN HOUSE (4 bedrooms)

The Main House has two distinct wings. The historic wing (the original ~1825 structure) holds two King bedrooms, the living room, and the dining room. Original heart pine hardwood floors run throughout. One King bedroom features original exposed wooden beams and the preserved servant staircase, enclosed behind clear plexiglass panels as a small living-history detail. The other has a romantic clawfoot tub.

The newer wing houses the expansive 500 sq ft master suite with its own private balcony, a Queen bedroom on the first floor with a walk-in shower, and a modern full kitchen. All four bedrooms have their own ensuite bathrooms.

Downstairs, gather in the living room around the 85" Smart TV, or cook together in the fully equipped kitchen.

THE COTTAGE (1 bedroom)

Steps away from the Main House, the detached cottage is a home away from home in its own right. Private entrance, King bedroom with ensuite bath, full kitchen, foosball table, and 65" Smart TV. A Queen sofa bed in the living room brings the cottage to a comfortable 2 to 4 sleepers. Ideal for grandparents who want their own space, teens who like their independence, or an extra couple.

THE POOL

The private 700 sq ft pool is fully fenced, with an integrated sun deck, a pergola for shade, and lounge furniture. Pool floats and noodles are stocked on-site. Open seasonally June through September, 8 AM to 9 PM. Whether it's a lazy afternoon float or a sunset swim after a beach day, this is where a lot of our guests spend the most time.

"The pool was the best! We had so much fun. We'd def come back." — Sara, July 2026 (5.0★)

OUTDOOR LIVING

Beyond the pool, the outdoor space stretches across 1.3 acres. A string-lit patio, a wood-burning fire pit for s'mores and stargazing, a cornhole set, and a full-size asphalt pickleball court (paddles, balls, and net all provided) round out the yard. There's also a gas BBQ grill.

The yard is naturally private. It's partially fenced on the street side with mature treelines providing over 100 feet of buffer on the neighboring sides.

(Firewood for the fire pit is available at Acme or Wawa nearby.)

THE BEACH

Multiple Cape May beaches are 5 to 10 minutes by car. Wildwood beaches are about 15. We've got you covered on the essentials: 10 beach chairs, 2 umbrellas, a pull cart, boogie boards, sand toys, a volleyball, a football, and 10 Cape May beach tags. (Beach tags need to be returned at checkout.)

RAINY DAY? NO PROBLEM

The 85" and 65" Smart TVs make movie marathons easy. The foosball table keeps things competitive, and the pickleball court is always there if the sun comes back out. Downtown Cape May's shops, restaurants, and Victorian architecture are 5 to 10 minutes away by car. Cape May is one of the most charming small towns on the East Coast, rain or shine.

A NOTE FROM A MULTI-GEN GROUP

"Our group of 9, multigenerational family of all ages, had one of the best vacations on the books. We enjoyed the large and well-stocked kitchen, the outdoor grill to cook meals, watched World Cup matches in the comfortable gathering spaces, and had tons of fun in the gorgeous pool. There's also a peaceful walking path tucked away where you can have a nice jog, walk, or bike ride to the Cold Spring museum and the brewery." — Tara, July 2026 (5.0★)

UNIQUE FEATURES

Self check-in via smart lock, arrive any time
Private 700 sq ft pool, fully fenced (June to September, 8 AM to 9 PM), floats and noodles stocked
Every bedroom has its own private ensuite bathroom
200-year-old original heart pine hardwood floors (historic wing only)
Preserved servant staircase behind clear plexiglass panels
Clawfoot tub in one of the historic King bedrooms
500 sq ft master suite with private balcony
First-floor Queen bedroom with walk-in shower
Full-size pickleball court with equipment and net provided
Foosball table in the cottage
Cornhole set in the backyard
Gas BBQ grill
Two full kitchens
1.3 private acres with natural treeline privacy
Rail trail access, walk or bike to Historic Cold Spring Village and the local brewery
5 min walk to Cape May Winery
Parking for up to 6 cars in the main driveway

PERFECT FOR

Family reunions, milestone birthdays, wedding party accommodations, bachelorette weekends, multi-generational vacations, and summer beach weeks. If your group values space, privacy, and character, this is your place.

WHAT WE PROVIDE

Eco-friendly shampoo, conditioner, body wash, hand soap, lotion in refillable dispensers
Complimentary medium roast coffee, creamer, and sugar
Fresh linens and towels, plus dark washcloths for makeup removal
Hair dryer in every bathroom
WiFi, central heat, and AC throughout
Two full sets of washer and dryer, one per building
Beach chairs, towels, 2 umbrellas, pull cart, and beach toys
10 Cape May beach tags (return at checkout)
Pool floats and noodles
Please bring: toothbrush, toothpaste, razors, deodorant, personal care items, and sunscreen.

LOCATION

Cape May Winery: 5 min walk
Rail trail: steps from the property, connects to Historic Cold Spring Village and Cold Spring Brewery
Historic Cold Spring Village: 2 min drive
Cape May beaches: 5 to 10 min drive
Washington Street Mall (shops, cafes, dining): 5 to 10 min drive
Cape May Lighthouse, Emlen Physick Estate, Victorian architecture walking tours: short drive
Hawk Haven Vineyard, Willow Creek Winery: short drive
Wildwood beaches: about 15 min drive
Local restaurants: The Ebbitt Room, Blue Pig Tavern, Washington Inn, Louisa's Cafe, Rusty Nail, Lucky Bones

CAPE MAY THROUGH THE YEAR

Cape May shines in every season. Summer (June to September) is prime beach and pool time. September brings the Food & Wine Festival. October is Victorian Weekend, and it's peak season for the town's world-renowned fall bird migration. November and December turn into Cape May Christmas, when the Victorian houses light up. May and June host the Cape May Music Festival. Whenever you visit, there's something on.

ACCESSIBILITY

Please note that both buildings require climbing stairs to reach the main entrance. The Main House entrance has 5 to 6 steps up to the front deck. The Cottage entrance has 1 to 2 steps. There is no ramp. Once inside the Main House, there is a first-floor Queen bedroom with a walk-in shower for anyone who prefers to avoid the interior staircase to the upper floors. If mobility is a concern for anyone in your group, please message us before booking so we can walk through the layout with you.

HOUSE RULES (summary)

Check-in 4 PM, check-out 10 AM
Age 25+ (or accompanied by a parent or guardian)
Quiet hours 10 PM to 8 AM; outdoor music ends 9 PM
No smoking anywhere on the property
2 well-trained dogs welcome, 30 lbs or under. Vaccinations required (rabies, distemper, bordetella). Pet fee is included once declared.. Dogs are not permitted in the pool area.
Small celebrations welcome with prior approval. This is not an event venue.
Pool: no lifeguard on duty, swim at your own risk. No diving. No glass, pets in the pool area.

A NOTE FROM YOUR HOST

Cape May has been my escape for years. I fell in love with the way this town blends colonial elegance with coastal ease, and when I found this 200-year-old estate on Seashore Road, I saw a chance to create something special. My goal is to give families and groups the kind of place where you can genuinely spread out, reconnect, and celebrate together.

I'm just a message away for anything you need before or during your stay. Looking forward to hosting your group.

Warmly,
Swati