We loved staying at Amy's Redwood Cottage and definitely would return. It is a far different (and much better) experience than staying in Crescent City!

The property is beautiful, surrounded by a forest of mature redwoods, along with a couple of stumps of ancient giants. The garden-like yard has plenty of outdoor furniture, a fire pit, and clean Hot Springs spa tub. It is very private and peaceful. Even the yard was usually silent except for birds and some wind in the tree tops. And no biting insects to hinder enjoyment of the outdoors.

This location was plenty convenient to attractions like the giant redwood groves and trailheads along US 199, or the nearby Tolowa Dunes State Park. Getting into Crescent City is also easy enough, most of the drive on excellent highway.

We found the house quite clean everywhere it counts (kitchen, bathroom, fresh linens, floors, spa tub). Because of the appealing garden view, we noticed that the windows in the kitchen and living room were sparking clean. The kitchen is well-enough equipped and appliances all work. The shower is nice, and hot water is fine. Furniture is very comfortable (great bed) and includes some very cute antiques.

We would have rated the cottage five stars except for a strong mold smell inside (despite weeks without rainfall) and some minor maintenance issues. Perhaps we are more sensitive than others to mold. Upon return each day we aired out the place as best we could, and it was okay after that. The cottage also could use the attention of a good handyman. Even though the cleaners are doing a great job, we noticed a number of small things that a resident would notice are not right (windows that barely operate, bathroom door doesn't close, slow drain in the sink, etc.). Overall these are quite minor, and to repeat: we would definitely stay here again... not even consider any other accommodations in the area. The experience here is unique and memorable. 'Wish we were there now!